Eastern Comma (Polygonia comma)
(c) Judy Gallagher, some rights reserved (CC BY-SA), uploaded by Judy Gallagher · CC BY-SA 4.0 (opens in a new tab) · iNaturalist (opens in a new tab)
Butterflies and mothsIn Cuyahoga County, Ohio

Eastern Comma

Polygonia comma (Harris, 1852)

Eastern Comma in all of Ohio
Kingdom
Animalia
Phylum
Arthropoda
Class
Insecta
Near Cuyahoga County

Range

Where it is recorded

Season shown in 2 of Ohio's 88 counties. Explore Ohio

  • No result yet (4)
  • Recorded, too few records for a result (62)
  • Recorded, season not shown (20)
  • Season shown (2)
Boundaries: U.S. Census Bureau, 2025 Cartographic Boundary Files, 1:500,000. Show as a table
Counties as a table
Eastern Comma by Ohio county: records and mapped range
CountyRecords
Adams County23 · Recorded, season not shown
Allen CountyRecorded, too few records for a result
Ashland CountyRecorded, too few records for a result
Ashtabula CountyRecorded, too few records for a result
Athens County23 · Recorded, season not shown
Auglaize CountyRecorded, too few records for a result
Belmont CountyRecorded, too few records for a result
Brown CountyRecorded, too few records for a result
Butler County46 · Recorded, season not shown
Carroll CountyRecorded, too few records for a result
Champaign CountyRecorded, too few records for a result
Clark CountyRecorded, too few records for a result
Clermont County43 · Recorded, season not shown
Clinton CountyRecorded, too few records for a result
Columbiana CountyRecorded, too few records for a result
Coshocton County23 · Recorded, season not shown
Crawford CountyRecorded, too few records for a result
Cuyahoga County64 · Season shown
Darke CountyRecorded, too few records for a result
Defiance CountyRecorded, too few records for a result
Delaware County25 · Recorded, season not shown
Erie CountyRecorded, too few records for a result
Fairfield CountyRecorded, too few records for a result
Fayette CountyRecorded, too few records for a result
Franklin County114 · Recorded, season not shown
Fulton CountyRecorded, too few records for a result
Gallia CountyRecorded, too few records for a result
Geauga CountyRecorded, too few records for a result
Greene County56 · Recorded, season not shown
Guernsey CountyRecorded, too few records for a result
Hamilton County111 · Season shown
Hancock County21 · Recorded, season not shown
Hardin CountyRecorded, too few records for a result
Harrison CountyRecorded, too few records for a result
Henry CountyRecorded, too few records for a result
Highland CountyRecorded, too few records for a result
Hocking County54 · Recorded, season not shown
Holmes CountyRecorded, too few records for a result
Huron CountyNo qualifying records yet
Jackson CountyRecorded, too few records for a result
Jefferson CountyRecorded, too few records for a result
Knox CountyRecorded, too few records for a result
Lake CountyRecorded, too few records for a result
Lawrence CountyRecorded, too few records for a result
Licking County36 · Recorded, season not shown
Logan CountyRecorded, too few records for a result
Lorain CountyRecorded, too few records for a result
Lucas County64 · Recorded, season not shown
Madison CountyRecorded, too few records for a result
Mahoning CountyRecorded, too few records for a result
Marion CountyRecorded, too few records for a result
Medina County45 · Recorded, season not shown
Meigs CountyNo qualifying records yet
Mercer CountyRecorded, too few records for a result
Miami CountyRecorded, too few records for a result
Monroe CountyRecorded, too few records for a result
Montgomery County126 · Recorded, season not shown
Morgan CountyRecorded, too few records for a result
Morrow CountyRecorded, too few records for a result
Muskingum CountyRecorded, too few records for a result
Noble CountyRecorded, too few records for a result
Ottawa County26 · Recorded, season not shown
Paulding CountyNo qualifying records yet
Perry CountyRecorded, too few records for a result
Pickaway CountyRecorded, too few records for a result
Pike CountyRecorded, too few records for a result
Portage County23 · Recorded, season not shown
Preble CountyRecorded, too few records for a result
Putnam CountyRecorded, too few records for a result
Richland CountyRecorded, too few records for a result
Ross CountyRecorded, too few records for a result
Sandusky CountyRecorded, too few records for a result
Scioto CountyRecorded, too few records for a result
Seneca CountyRecorded, too few records for a result
Shelby CountyRecorded, too few records for a result
Stark County69 · Recorded, season not shown
Summit County55 · Recorded, season not shown
Trumbull CountyRecorded, too few records for a result
Tuscarawas CountyRecorded, too few records for a result
Union CountyRecorded, too few records for a result
Van Wert CountyNo qualifying records yet
Vinton CountyRecorded, too few records for a result
Warren County25 · Recorded, season not shown
Washington CountyRecorded, too few records for a result
Wayne County31 · Recorded, season not shown
Williams CountyRecorded, too few records for a result
Wood CountyRecorded, too few records for a result
Wyandot CountyRecorded, too few records for a result

No mapped range from the range source used, the USGS Gap Analysis Project, which maps land vertebrates only.

Season

When it is recorded

In Cuyahoga County

Late March to early October, middle week Aug 9–15

Show over the bars
Recording in Cuyahoga County · records of all species each week, 92,154 in all

Records per week from 64 records in 9 of the 10 years from 2016 to 2025. Shows when people recorded it, not how common it is. The grey bars show how many records of all species were made here each week, so you can see when recording itself was high or low; the season is not adjusted by them.

Recorded on 57 dates. Latest record: October 2025.

Show as a table
Records of Eastern Comma in Cuyahoga County each week, and records of all species
WeekRecords of Eastern CommaYears recordedRecords of all species
Jan 4–1000468
Jan 11–1700502
Jan 18–2400393
Jan 25–3100380
Feb 1–700590
Feb 8–1400504
Feb 15–2100455
Feb 22–2800583
Mar 1–700567
Mar 8–1411750
Mar 15–2111819
Mar 22–2811780
Mar 29 – Apr 4221,014
Apr 5–11111,655
Apr 12–18322,306
Apr 19–25001,857
Apr 26 – May 2004,135
May 3–9222,830
May 10–16112,640
May 17–23002,938
May 24–30002,903
May 31 – Jun 6002,621
Jun 7–13112,326
Jun 14–20002,465
Jun 21–27322,426
Jun 28 – Jul 4422,632
Jul 5–11002,765
Jul 12–18112,898
Jul 19–25222,860
Jul 26 – Aug 1332,736
Aug 2–8533,021
Aug 9–15222,627
Aug 16–22222,732
Aug 23–29542,388
Aug 30 – Sep 5533,076
Sep 6–12323,578
Sep 13–19113,735
Sep 20–26433,328
Sep 27 – Oct 3322,834
Oct 4–10632,275
Oct 11–17111,937
Oct 18–24001,181
Oct 25–31001,172
Nov 1–711893
Nov 8–1400854
Nov 15–2100485
Nov 22–2800552
Nov 29 – Dec 500448
Dec 6–1200498
Dec 13–1900458
Dec 20–2600575
Dec 27 – Jan 200709

Reported as an adult

Usually reported as an adult late March to early October, middle week Aug 9–15.

From 63 records that are marked as adults. Not every photo is marked with a life stage, so this shows when people reported it as an adult, not when adults are about.

Reported as a caterpillar

Only 1 records here are marked as caterpillars, too few to show a caterpillar season. One needs at least 20 records from 5 different years.

In Ohio

Mid-March to mid-October, middle week Aug 2–8

Show over the bars
Recording in Ohio · records of all species each week, 1,691,199 in all

Records per week from 2,140 records in 10 of the 10 years from 2016 to 2025. Shows when people recorded it, not how common it is. The grey bars show how many records of all species were made here each week, so you can see when recording itself was high or low; the season is not adjusted by them.

Recorded on 1,014 dates. Latest record: December 2025.

Show as a table
Records of Eastern Comma in Ohio each week, and records of all species
WeekRecords of Eastern CommaYears recordedRecords of all species
Jan 4–10006,211
Jan 11–17005,146
Jan 18–24004,645
Jan 25–31114,698
Feb 1–7006,023
Feb 8–14225,888
Feb 15–21425,436
Feb 22–28636,846
Mar 1–72358,321
Mar 8–1433810,384
Mar 15–2147612,620
Mar 22–2832613,949
Mar 29 – Apr 460819,661
Apr 5–1163826,860
Apr 12–18931039,925
Apr 19–25441041,623
Apr 26 – May 242956,391
May 3–929952,952
May 10–1623853,785
May 17–2320757,698
May 24–309454,651
May 31 – Jun 631853,099
Jun 7–1368853,700
Jun 14–2065956,625
Jun 21–2774955,361
Jun 28 – Jul 457958,477
Jul 5–11401061,336
Jul 12–1833964,722
Jul 19–2567869,753
Jul 26 – Aug 192959,416
Aug 2–8941059,712
Aug 9–151111055,994
Aug 16–22931054,328
Aug 23–2977951,772
Aug 30 – Sep 576857,167
Sep 6–1267959,075
Sep 13–19841054,543
Sep 20–2673945,860
Sep 27 – Oct 3751043,180
Oct 4–1094937,841
Oct 11–17901030,824
Oct 18–24451021,156
Oct 25–3129819,021
Nov 1–730714,172
Nov 8–1423712,621
Nov 15–21637,965
Nov 22–28838,136
Nov 29 – Dec 5116,083
Dec 6–12216,004
Dec 13–19225,423
Dec 20–26115,661
Dec 27 – Jan 2118,459

Reported as an adult

Usually reported as an adult mid-March to mid-October, middle week Jul 26 – Aug 1.

From 2,044 records that are marked as adults. Not every photo is marked with a life stage, so this shows when people reported it as an adult, not when adults are about.

Reported as a caterpillar

No caterpillar season shown here. Most records come from a single year, so a season is not shown yet.

What these results show

These results show when people recorded a species, not when or where it occurs. Missing weeks and low counts do not mean absence or scarcity, and counts are not abundance. Contributed records reflect where, when and what people chose to observe.

Relatives

In the same genus

Other Polygonia recorded in Cuyahoga County

Identification

How to identify it

Telling it apart

From what Ohio’s records show. Only what the records support is shown.

Often confused with

  • Question Mark Polygonia interrogationisOften confused in Ohio: 122 identifications in Ohio named one where the other was meant
  • Pearl Crescent Phyciodes tharos12 identifications worldwide named one where the other was meant

From iNaturalist’s similar-species counts, refreshed monthly: confusions in Ohio first, then worldwide. Only species with an Ohio result are listed.

Land cover where it is recorded

Land coverIts recordsAll Ohio records
Forest53%31%
Developed26%49%
Farmland10%11%
Wetland8%5%
Open water2%3%
Grassland and shrub1%0.9%
Barren0.4%0.6%

From 952 records placed within 100 m, beside all Ohio records placed the same way. People record where they go, so this shows where records come from, not where the species lives. Land cover: USGS Annual NLCD, 2025 (opens in a new tab)

Sources

Where these results come from

  • Records from iNaturalist research-grade observations and expert-identified GBIF datasets, CC0, CC BY and CC BY-NC. Sources
  • Seasons use the published method and its evidence thresholds. Methods
  • See it on iNaturalist (opens in a new tab)OpenPhenology is independent and not affiliated with iNaturalist.

Records behind the Cuyahoga County result

64 records from 1 dataset.

To cite: the GBIF download doi:10.15468/dl.y2jkt8 (opens in a new tab).

A spreadsheet (CSV) with a link to each record, on iNaturalist or GBIF. Records whose location was hidden by the observer or the source are counted but not linked.